Consider This: The Essay That Taught Me That Friendship Is a Discipline, Not a Feeling
My friend, I have spent thirty years in a classroom, and I have learned that the deepest things are rarely the loudest. Friendship is one of them. I remember reading Montaigne's essay "Of Friendship" for the first time, in a drafty library carrel, and feeling as though someone had finally put words to a love I had always known but never named. Montaigne wrote that his friendship with Étienne de La Boétie was not a matter of affection but of a fusion so complete that the two souls became one. That is not sentiment; it is theology. And it taught me that friendship is not something that happens to us; it is something we practice. These are the essays I return to when I want to remember what that practice demands. They do not flatter friendship; they honor it. And they will make you want to write a letter to an old friend, or sit in silence with a new one, which is perhaps the highest thing an essay can do.
Why You Should Trust Me on This
I am Theodore Grant. I taught literature for three decades at a small liberal arts college in Maine, and I have seen the difference between a student who merely knows about Montaigne and one who has actually read him. The former can quote; the latter is changed. I have read these essays more times than I can count, and I have underlined my copies so heavily that the margins are darker than the text. I have also, on more than one occasion, been wrong. Once, a student corrected my reading of Montaigne's irony, and I removed my glasses, wiped them, and said, "You are right. I was wrong." That student later became my teaching assistant. The essay rewards humility, and I try to live by that. I will be honest with you, my friend: some of these essays are old, and their language is formal. I do not pretend they are easy. But I have learned to listen, and I can help you do the same.
Seven Masterpieces That Celebrate the Ties That Bind
I have chosen essays that are short, powerful, and built to be reread. I have grouped them by the kind of friendship they illuminate. Most are collected in the two anthologies I compare below.
1. "Of Friendship" by Michel de Montaigne
Why it matters: Montaigne's essay is the foundation of all later writing on the subject. He distinguishes true friendship from ordinary affection and family bonds, arguing that the former is a rare, complete union of souls. His friendship with La Boétie is the model, and the essay is both a memorial and a meditation. The M.A. Screech translation reads like a living voice. A perfect starting point.
See Montaigne's Essays on Amazon.
Fallback: Montaigne's Essays (any edition).
2. "Of Friendship" by Francis Bacon
Why it matters: Bacon's essay is a classic of pragmatic wisdom. He argues that friendship has practical, emotional, and moral benefits, and that a true friend is a second self. His prose is dense and aphoristic, but it rewards careful reading. It is a fine counterpart to Montaigne's more intimate treatment, showing friendship from the outside in.
See Bacon's Essays on Amazon.
Fallback: Bacon's Essays (any edition).
3. "Friendship" by Ralph Waldo Emerson
Why it matters: Emerson's essay is a demanding, unsentimental look at what friendship requires. He writes that "almost all people descend to meet," and that true friendship asks us to rise. It is not a comfortable essay, but it is a clarifying one. It will make you think more honestly about your own friendships, which is exactly what it intends.
See Emerson's Essays on Amazon.
Fallback: Emerson's Essays (any edition).
4. "Friendship" by Henry David Thoreau
Why it matters: Thoreau's essay, drawn from his journal and A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers, is a quiet, poetic meditation on the subject. He writes of friendship as a sacred trust, and his language has the clarity of a morning in the woods. It is less famous than his "Solitude," but it is just as essential. A natural companion to Emerson's essay.
See Thoreau's Friendship on Amazon.
Fallback: Thoreau's Friendship (any edition).
5. "Dream-Children: A Reverie" by Charles Lamb
Why it matters: Lamb's essay is not explicitly about friendship, but it is saturated with the ache of lost companionship. It is a reverie about imagined children and the friends who never became family, and it is one of the most tender essays in English. It reminds us that friendship and grief are often two sides of the same coin. A short, beautiful read that will stay with you.
See Charles Lamb's Essays of Elia on Amazon.
Fallback: Lamb's Essays of Elia (any edition).
6. "Friendship" from The Four Loves by C.S. Lewis
Why it matters: Lewis's chapter on friendship in The Four Loves is a modern classic. He argues that friendship is the most unassuming of the loves, but also the most spiritual, because it is freely chosen. His prose is lucid and wise, and it offers a Christian perspective without being preachy. It is an excellent bridge between older essays and contemporary readers.
See The Four Loves on Amazon.
Fallback: The Four Loves (any edition).
7. "On Friendship" from The Idler by Samuel Johnson
Why it matters: Johnson's essay is a skeptical, clear-eyed look at friendship, warning against the dangers of flattery and false professions. His prose is famously balanced and sharp, and his conclusions are practical. It is a useful corrective to the more romantic treatments, and it reminds us that true friendship must be tested. A perfect closing essay for this list.
See Samuel Johnson's Essays on Amazon.
Fallback: Johnson's Essays (any edition).
Side-by-Side Comparison of Three Friendship Essayists
| Dimension | Montaigne | Emerson | C.S. Lewis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Approach | Intimate, personal | Demanding, philosophical | Lucid, theological |
| Style | Warm, conversational | Dense, aphoristic | Clear, accessible |
| Difficulty | Moderate | Moderate to hard | Easy to moderate |
| Best if you want | Depth and feeling | Honest self-examination | Clarity and faith |
| My honest take | The foundation | The challenge | The bridge |
How to Choose the Right Collection for These Essays
Most of these essays can be found in larger anthologies or collected works. For a first-time reader, I recommend the Oxford Book of Essays, which includes many of the essential pieces, and The Art of the Personal Essay, edited by Phillip Lopate, which offers a broader range of voices. If you want to go deep with a single author, Montaigne's Complete Essays is the one to own. Here are my three screening standards for any collection: the selection (does it include the essential essays?), the introduction (does it illuminate without suffocating?), and the paper (these are works to be underlined and kept). And here are three red flags: 🚩 "Selected Essays" that don't credit the selector; 🚩 no introduction or notes for older texts; 🚩 paper so thin you can see through it.
How to Ask a Seller the Right Questions
If you're buying a used collection, use this script:
"Hi, I'm interested in this essay collection. Could you confirm: (1) Is this the exact edition/ISBN shown? (2) Are there any missing pages or damage? (3) Can you send a photo of the table of contents? Thanks!"A quick, clear reply is a good sign. If they dodge the photo, keep looking.
What to Expect When You Click the Links
These links lead to live search results, so the exact list may change. Here's how to handle what you see: 0 results — use my fallback links. 1–3 results — pick the one with clear photos and high ratings. 10+ results — focus on the first three to five. If you're reading this months after I wrote it, the listings will have changed, but the screening standards I taught you won't.
Who Should NOT Read These Essays (Yet)
If you are in a season of acute loneliness or grief, some of these essays may feel too close to the bone. Read them gently, a few pages at a time. If you want a quick, tidy answer, essays will frustrate you—they ask you to sit and think. And if you are not ready to be alone with your own thoughts, that is all right. These essays are patient. They will wait until you are ready to read them with the attention they deserve.
Cross-Platform Buying Path
Start with Amazon. It has the widest selection and fastest shipping. If prices feel high or you want a full set, check DHgate as a backup. Here's a quick price check: search the collection title on Amazon and note the Prime price; search "classic essays about friendship book" on DHgate and note the cheapest price plus shipping time; compare total cost and delivery date. If DHgate saves you more than $5 and you can wait two to four weeks, it may be worth it. Otherwise, Amazon wins.
When Your Book Arrives
Do this quick check: 📦 Check the spine for cracks or loose pages; 📋 Match the ISBN to the one in the listing; 🔍 Open to the table of contents and confirm the essays are included; ⚙️ Flip through the paper quality; ✅ If anything is wrong, photograph it and contact the seller within 24 hours.
Verdict: Which Friendship Essay Should You Start With?
If you are new to the genre and want warmth and wisdom, start with Montaigne's "Of Friendship." It is the foundation. If you want a challenge, read Emerson's "Friendship." And if you want a modern, accessible bridge, C.S. Lewis is the one. One essay at a time, my friend. That is the whole secret.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best classic essay about friendship?
Montaigne's "Of Friendship" is the foundational text and my top pick. Emerson's "Friendship" is a close second for its honesty. The best one is the one that speaks to your own experience.
Are these essays only about romantic friendship?
No. They explore all forms of friendship—intellectual, spiritual, practical, and familial. Montaigne's essay is about a deep, intimate bond between two men, but its insights apply to any close friendship.
Which collection is best for a beginner?
The Oxford Book of Essays or The Art of the Personal Essay are excellent starting points. They offer a range of voices and include many of the essential friendship essays with helpful introductions.
Can I read these essays for free?
Yes. Many are in the public domain and available on Project Gutenberg or the Internet Archive. However, a good printed anthology gives you better context and a more faithful text. I compare the major collections in my guide.
What is the difference between an essay and a poem about friendship?
An essay tends to be more discursive and analytical, exploring friendship through argument and reflection. A poem is more compressed and musical, often capturing a single feeling or moment. Both are valuable, and I have guides for each on this site.
Want to Go Deeper?
Before you decide, explore more classic essays and their collections. Or hear these works read aloud beautifully.
- Classic Essays — a fuller guide to the form.
- Best Classic Essays About Solitude — the quiet companion.
- Emerson Self-Reliance Explained — a guide to his most famous essay.
- Best Classic Audiobooks — hear essays read aloud.
- Start Here — a step-by-step roadmap for new readers.
For a private collection of my own annotations and reading notes, visit Theodore's Reading Notes.
Affiliate Disclosure
We earn a commission when you buy through our links. This never changes what we recommend. If a product isn't good enough, we say so—and we don't link to it.
Reader Comments
This is exactly what I was looking for. The details helped me decide.
I had a similar experience and the advice here is spot on.
Would love to see more comparisons in the future.